The sinking of the RMS Titanic in the early hours of April 15, 1912, remains one of the most enduring and tragic events of the 20th century. Amidst the tales of heroism and loss, the story of the ship's officers, who bore the immense responsibility of navigating the crisis, continues to captivate and provoke debate. Among them, First Officer William McMaster Murdoch stands as a figure of particular interest and controversy. His career, marked by dedication and a steady climb through the ranks, culminated in his presence on the bridge during the catastrophic night of April 14-15, 1912. This article will explore the life and career of Officer Murdoch, meticulously examining his role in the events leading up to and during the sinking of the Titanic. Furthermore, it will delve into accounts of his personality and address the enduring controversy surrounding the possibility of his suicide in the disaster's final moments. Finally, this analysis will confront the deeply damaging and historically inaccurate portrayal of Murdoch in the 1997 film Titanic, highlighting its detrimental impact on his legacy and the subsequent efforts to restore his true image.
 |
| Officer Murdoch during the night of the sinking (self-made digital ilustration) |
Early Life and Career: Forging a Path on the Seas
William McMaster Murdoch was born on February 28, 1873, in Dalbeattie, Kirkcudbrightshire, Scotland, a region steeped in maritime tradition. Dalbeattie, while not a major port itself, had a strong connection to the sea, with many of its young men pursuing careers in maritime professions. His father, Captain Samuel Murdoch, was a respected master mariner, and it was perhaps inevitable that young William would follow in his footsteps, developing an early affinity for the sea.
After graduating with top honors from Dalbeattie High School in 1887, he began a five-year apprenticeship with William Joyce & Coy in Liverpool, but his competence allowed him to pass his Second Mate's Certificate after only four years. He is believed to have sailed with his uncle, Captain John Murdoch, on the Loch Urr. At age 15 in 1888, he served aboard the Charles Cotesworth, enduring a harsh apprenticeship that included rounding Cape Horn. He left the Charles Cotesworth in 1892 and, after obtaining his 2nd mate's certificate in 1893, served as second officer on the Iquique, captained by his father, Samuel Murdoch; this was their only voyage together. During this time, he may have lived in Liverpool with his father and also met Stanley Lord, who would later captain the Californian. In 1895, Murdoch earned his 1st mate's certificate and became First Mate on the Saint Cuthbert. He achieved the highest nautical qualification, the Extra Master's Certificate, on his first attempt - a rare feat in that era -in 1896 at the age of 23, unlike his future Titanic colleagues Edward John Smith and Henry Tingle Wilde. Described as being 5' 8 1/2" to 5' 9" tall with fair complexion, brown hair, and hazel grey/hazel brown eyes, Murdoch continued his career, serving as first mate on the Lydgate from 1897 to 1899. He also trained as a Lieutenant in the Royal Naval Reserve during the Boer War, which qualified him to join the White Star Line as a steamship officer in 1899.
 |
| William M. Murdoch during his first years at WSL |
Service with the White Star Line and Appointment to the Titanic: A Testament to Professionalism
Murdoch joined the prestigious White Star Line in 1900, a company at the forefront of transatlantic passenger travel, renowned for its luxurious and technologically advanced liners. His service with the White Star Line saw him rise steadily through the ranks, demonstrating consistent efficiency, reliability, and a calm demeanor that earned him the respect of his colleagues and superiors. He served as a junior officer on various prominent White Star vessels, including the Medic, Runic, Germanic, Oceanic, and Adriatic. On each ship, he took on increasing responsibility, proving his capability in handling the demands of larger vessels and more senior roles. By 1912, at the age of 39, Murdoch had established himself as one of the company's most capable and experienced officers, marked by his successful attainment of his Extra-Master's certificate and his solid track record.
His assignment to the RMS Titanic, the White Star Line's newest and grandest vessel, was a significant recognition of his standing within the company. He was initially assigned the prestigious role of Chief Officer for the maiden voyage. However, in a decision made by the company, not solely Captain Edward Smith's personal choice as is sometimes mistakenly believed, Chief Officer Henry Tingle Wilde from the Olympic was transferred to the Titanic for the maiden voyage due to his seniority and experience with the Olympic-class ships. This corporate decision led to a last-minute reshuffling of the officer ranks, with Murdoch being reassigned to the position of First Officer. While this change altered his initial assignment, it still placed him in a critical senior role on the bridge during the fateful maiden voyage.
 |
| Last photo fo Murdoch (on the right) |
Role on the Night of the Sinking: Moments of Crisis and Command
On the night of April 14-15, 1912, First Officer William McMaster Murdoch was the senior officer on the bridge during the crucial 10:00 PM to 2:00 AM watch. He had taken over the watch from Second Officer Charles Lightoller. Also present on the bridge were Sixth Officer James Moody and Quartermaster Robert Hichens at the helm. The night was clear, cold, and moonless, with an unusually calm sea that made spotting icebergs, which often reveal themselves by breaking waves at their base, particularly challenging.
At approximately 11:40 PM, the ship's lookouts, Frederick Fleet and Reginald Lee, stationed in the crow's nest, spotted a large iceberg directly ahead. It was Sixth Officer James Moody who received the initial telephone call from the crow's nest reporting, "Iceberg right ahead!" Moody immediately relayed this critical information to First Officer Murdoch. Murdoch's reaction was instantaneous. According to testimony from Moody and Hichens, Murdoch sprang into action, giving the order to Quartermaster Hichens to steer "hard-a-starboard." In 1912 tiller practice, this command meant pushing the tiller to the starboard (right) side, which would angle the rudder to port (left), causing the ship's bow to turn to port (left) – an attempt to steer away from the iceberg. Simultaneously, Murdoch signaled the engine room with the engine order telegraph, and accounts from below decks consistently indicate that a "full stop" order was received. While the order was prompt, the Titanic's immense size and speed meant she could not react quickly enough to avoid the obstacle entirely. The ship's starboard side scraped along the submerged portion of the iceberg, resulting in a series of critical ruptures below the waterline.
Following the collision, as the gravity of the situation became apparent, Murdoch played a crucial role in the initial assessment of the damage from the bridge and the subsequent efforts to launch lifeboats. Unlike Second Officer Lightoller, who went to the port side boat deck and later the starboard side, Murdoch remained on the bridge and the starboard side boat deck, overseeing the preparation and loading of the lifeboats on that side of the ship. Survivor testimonies, including that of Second Officer Charles Lightoller (who later went to the starboard side to assist), consistently portray Murdoch as being diligently engaged in his duties, maintaining order, and assisting passengers into the lifeboats. Lightoller testified that Murdoch was "carrying out his duties as First Officer in a proper and seamanlike manner" (British Wreck Commissioner's Inquiry, Question 1276).
Passenger accounts from the starboard side also speak of an officer who was active and resolute. While an earlier version of this text incorrectly attributed a specific megaphone anecdote to Lawrence Beesley, Beesley's book The Loss of the SS. Titanic does feature his observation of an officer he believed to be Murdoch during the lifeboat loading: "An officer—I think First Officer Murdock—came striding along the deck, clad in a long coat, from his manner and face evidently in great agitation, but determined and resolute; he looked over the side and shouted to the boats being lowered: 'Lower away, and when afloat, row around to the gangway and wait for orders.' 'Aye, aye, sir,' was the reply; and the officer passed by and went across the ship to the port side." This description, regardless of definitive identification, paints a picture of a senior officer acting decisively under pressure. Fourth Officer Joseph Boxhall also testified about his conversation with Captain Smith regarding the ship's position and the sending of distress signals shortly after the collision, indicating the officers were focused on immediate emergency procedures. Murdoch oversaw the loading of several lifeboats from the starboard side, including lifeboats 7, 5, 3, and 1, and collapsible boats C and A, making difficult decisions regarding the application of the "women and children first" policy and the numbers of people allowed to embark.
Personality and Reputation: A Quiet Professional
Accounts from those who knew William McMaster Murdoch consistently depict him as a dedicated, professional, and highly capable officer. He was generally described as a quiet and reserved man, known for his diligence, competence, and reliability. Colleagues on previous ships and those who served with him on the Titanic noted his calm demeanor and his focused approach to his duties. His professional reputation within the White Star Line and the broader maritime community was one of competence and trustworthiness. While not prone to outward displays of emotion, his actions in moments of responsibility were marked by efficiency and a steady hand. Testimonies from the official inquiries and accounts from survivors generally support the view of Murdoch as a responsible and dedicated officer who performed his duties to the best of his ability under immense and unprecedented pressure.
Survivors of the Titanic also offered glimpses into Murdoch's character during the chaotic evacuation. Many recalled his firm but fair approach in managing the crowds and ensuring that the "women and children first" policy was implemented. His actions in directing passengers to the lifeboats and maintaining order on the starboard side of the deck suggest a man who was focused on his duty and determined to do his best in an unimaginable situation. While he may not have been the most outwardly gregarious of officers, the accounts consistently portray him as a dedicated and responsible professional who commanded the respect of his colleagues and the passengers under his charge.
The Controversy of Possible Suicide: Examining Fragmented Accounts
The final moments of the Titanic's sinking were a maelstrom of chaos, terror, and desperate attempts at survival, rendering precise and universally consistent accounts a historical challenge. Among the most contentious points of debate is the fate of First Officer William McMaster Murdoch, specifically the lingering speculation surrounding a possible suicide in the disaster's final minutes. Examining the fragmented testimonies reveals a stark divergence in eyewitness accounts, with some narratives suggesting a dramatic end while others firmly attest to his continued dedication to duty.
| The infamous scene from the 1997 Titanic movie |
Some accounts from survivors, though often given under extreme duress and filtered through trauma, have been interpreted as supporting the theory of a senior officer's suicide. Third Class Passenger Eugene Daly, for instance, provided testimony that included seeing an officer take his own life. As cited in various sources drawing on inquiry transcripts, Daly recounted seeing an officer shoot two men who rushed a boat and then turn the gun on himself, stating, "He shot them and then he shot himself." Similarly, the account of George Rheims, a saloon passenger, also mentions seeing an officer shoot himself, though his testimony is less specific regarding the circumstances. These accounts, while not definitively identifying Murdoch, have been central to the speculation, often attributed to him given his prominent position on the boat deck during the critical final stages of evacuation on the starboard side.
However, these interpretations are strongly contested by testimonies from individuals who were in positions to observe Murdoch directly and for more extended periods in the disaster's final moments. Second Officer Charles Lightoller, the senior surviving officer and a close colleague of Murdoch, vehemently denied any suggestion of suicide by any officer. Throughout his extensive testimony at both the U.S. and British inquiries, Lightoller consistently praised the conduct of his fellow officers, emphasizing their unwavering commitment to their duties. When specifically questioned about reports of an officer shooting himself, Lightoller was unequivocal, stating at the British Inquiry: "I did not see any officer shoot himself or any other person." His position as the senior surviving officer lends significant weight to his denial.
Further countering the suicide narrative are the accounts of passengers who witnessed Murdoch's actions on the boat deck. Colonel Archibald Gracie IV, a first-class passenger who survived the sinking and meticulously documented the events on the boat deck in his book, recounts seeing Murdoch actively involved in launching Collapsible boat A in the final minutes. Gracie describes Murdoch working tirelessly and effectively, exhibiting no signs of despair or suicidal intent. His account portrays Murdoch as focused on the critical task at hand. Similarly, Laura Mabel Francatelli, who was rescued in Emergency Lifeboat No. 1 (not Collapsible D as previously stated), believed she saw Murdoch near Collapsible A in the final moments. While some interpretations of her later recollections have been used to support the suicide theory, claiming she saw a shooting from afar, it is crucial to note the considerable distance and confusion that would have made a clear identification and interpretation of events extremely difficult from a lifeboat already pulling away from the ship. As many Titanic historians, including those whose research is compiled on resources like the Paul Lee's Titanic Resource Site, point out, the reliability of eyewitness accounts from a distance in darkness and panic is inherently limited.
Comparing these disparate testimonies highlights the difficulty in definitively establishing Murdoch's fate. The accounts suggesting suicide are few, often lacking specific identification of the officer, and come from witnesses who may have been further away or more susceptible to misinterpreting events in the chaos. Conversely, the testimonies from fellow officers and passengers who were in closer proximity depict a man dedicated to his duty until the very end. The lack of any corroborating evidence from the other surviving officers further weakens the suicide theory. While the sheer stress of the situation was undoubtedly immense, the balance of evidence, particularly from those in a position to observe him closely, points towards First Officer William McMaster Murdoch tragically perishing while fulfilling his responsibilities, likely swept into the sea in the final moments as the ship sank. The controversy endures, fueled by the emotional weight of the disaster and the lack of a definitive, universally accepted account of his final fate.
The Portrayal in the 1997 Film Titanic and its Impact: A Stain on His Memory
James Cameron's 1997 blockbuster film Titanic included a dramatic and highly controversial scene depicting First Officer William McMaster Murdoch shooting two passengers who were attempting to force their way onto a lifeboat and then, overcome by guilt and despair, taking his own life. This portrayal sparked immediate and intense criticism from Murdoch's surviving relatives, particularly his nephew, Samuel Scott Murdoch, and the community of Dalbeattie, who viewed it as a damaging and unfounded smear on the character of a man who died heroically in the service of others.
Historical inaccuracies in the film's depiction of Murdoch are widely acknowledged by Titanic historians and researchers. There is no credible evidence from survivor testimonies or the official inquiries to definitively support the scene of Murdoch shooting passengers or himself. While the film aimed for dramatic effect, its portrayal of a real historical figure in such a negative light caused significant and lasting damage to Murdoch's public image. The film's depiction created a sensationalized and ultimately false narrative that overshadowed Murdoch's years of dedicated service and his courageous actions during the actual sinking. Many viewers, unaware of the historical debate and the lack of factual basis for the scene, accepted the film's portrayal as truth, leading to a widespread misperception of Officer Murdoch's character and his role in the disaster.
Reclaiming Murdoch's Legacy: Efforts Towards Historical Accuracy and Remembrance
In the years following the release of Titanic, a concerted effort has been made by Murdoch's family, the people of Dalbeattie, and numerous historians and Titanic enthusiasts to correct the inaccurate portrayal and to honor his memory as a dedicated and ultimately heroic officer. The Murdoch Memorial Cairn in his hometown stands as a permanent tribute to his life and service. His nephew Scott Murdoch actively campaigned for a retraction and an apology from the filmmakers, although this was never fully realized to his satisfaction.
 |
| The memorial at Dalbeattie town hall to First Officer William McMaster Murdoch |
Historians and authors have continued to publish works that present a more accurate account of Murdoch's actions on the night of the sinking, emphasizing his professionalism and the difficult decisions he had to make under immense pressure. For instance, Stephanie Barczewski's book Titanic: A Night Remembered (2004) offers a balanced perspective on Murdoch's role, acknowledging the challenges he faced while highlighting his efforts to save lives. Documentaries and online resources have also played a part in disseminating more accurate information about his life and career. The controversy surrounding the film's portrayal has served as a reminder of the importance of historical accuracy in popular culture and the potential for fictionalized accounts to have a lasting impact on the public perception of real historical figures. The ongoing efforts to reclaim Murdoch's legacy aim to ensure that he is remembered not for a baseless and sensationalized depiction, but for his dedication to his profession and his actions in the face of a devastating tragedy.
Conclusion: Remembering Duty, Challenging Misrepresentation, and Honoring a Hero
Officer William McMaster Murdoch's life was one of unwavering dedication to the sea, culminating in his role as First Officer on the ill-fated RMS Titanic. His actions on the night of the sinking, marked by prompt responses and diligent efforts to manage the crisis and evacuate passengers, reflect his professionalism and commitment to duty. While the theory of his suicide remains a point of contention with limited conclusive evidence, the damaging portrayal of him in the 1997 film Titanic as a dishonorable officer who took his own life is a significant misrepresentation that has unfairly tarnished his memory. The subsequent efforts by his family, his community, and historians to reclaim his true legacy are a testament to the importance of historical accuracy and the enduring respect for a man who, in the face of unimaginable tragedy, did his best to fulfill his responsibilities. William McMaster Murdoch should be remembered not for a fictionalized and sensationalized depiction, but as a dedicated officer who made the ultimate sacrifice in the service of others.
References
Barczewski, S. (2006). Titanic: A Very British Disaster. Continuum.
Beesley, L. (1912). The Loss of the SS. Titanic: Its Story and Its Lessons. Houghton Mifflin Company.
Boxhall, J. (1912). Testimony to the British Wreck Commissioner's Inquiry.
Daly, E. (1912). Testimony to the U.S. Senate Inquiry.
Davenport-Hines, R. (1998). Titanic Lives: Myths and Realities of the Most Famous Shipwreck. HarperCollins.
Gracie, A. (1913). The Truth About the Titanic. Mitchell Kennerley.
Halpern, S. (2011). Report into the Loss of the SS. Titanic: A Centennial Reappraisal. The History Press.
Lightoller, C. H. (1912). Testimony to the British Wreck Commissioner's Inquiry.
Lightoller, C. H. (1935). Titanic and Other Ships. Nicholson and Watson.
Lord, W. (1955). A Night to Remember. Henry Holt and Company.
Maltin, T. (2012). A Very Deceiving Night: The Titanic in Photographs and Eyewitness Accounts. Andre Deutsch.
Moody, J. (1912). Testimony to the British Wreck Commissioner's Inquiry.
Paul Lee's Titanic Resource Site. (n.d.). The Suicide of a Titanic Officer? Retrieved from
Rheims, G. (1912). Account of the Sinking of the Titanic.
United Kingdom, Parliament. (1912). Report of the British Wreck Commissioner on the Loss of the Titanic (Cd. 6352). His Majesty's Stationery Office.
United States Senate. (1912). Titanic Disaster: Hearings Before a Subcommittee of the Committee on Commerce, United States Senate, Sixty-Second Congress, Second Session.
Wade, W. C. (1979). The Titanic: End of a Dream. Penguin Books.
